Steel Frames vs Timber Frames: Which is Best for Your Home?
The frame of your home is its backbone. Holding the entire structure together and making the building strong, durable, and long-lasting. So, choosing the right material affects everything from comfort to functionality.
Will you go for the modern style of steel frames or timeless charm of framing timber?
Each option has its strengths and drawbacks. Let us put all their pros and cons in front of each other. So, you can choose what suits you the most.
Here at Ply Supply, our mission is to supply the best products on the market. From timber frames of Australia to outdoor composite decking and plywood. Our expert approved range meets all the quality standards and strength checks.
Let’s start our steel vs timber framing guide.
Steel Frames | Modern Option for Strength
Steel is introduced as a framing material in the 1980s and being used since then. Initially it was preferred for commercial purposes only. Now, making its way towards the residential side too.
They are designed to overcome the weaknesses of wooden frames and claim more durability. But their pre-assembled columns and beams don’t leave much room for adjustments. Let’s talk about all the pros and cons offered by them.
Pros of Steel Frames
Steel framing has become increasingly popular in modern Australian homes. Due to its strength, durability, and resistance to environmental threats.
Here are the main benefits of steel framing.
1. Lightweight Yet Strong
Steel is surprisingly lightweight compared to timber when considering its strength. This makes it easier to transport, lift, and install, especially on larger building sites.
A steel frame can hold significant weight without adding bulk to your structure. So, it is perfect for homes with large open spaces or modern architectural designs.
2. Longevity and Durability
One of the biggest advantages of steel frames is their lifespan. Steel doesn’t shrink, or crack over time like timber can.
You should choose it if you need a long-lasting structure maintaining its shape for decades. It is also resistant to moisture, making it ideal for homes in humid or coastal areas.
3. Pest Resistance
Termites and borers are a constant threat in Australia, especially in warmer regions. Steel is 100% pest-resistant, which can give you peace of mind without any pest treatment.
Unlike timber frames, you’ll never have to worry about termites compromising your home’s structure.
4. Fire Resistance
Steel is non-combustible, giving excellent protection in bushfire-prone areas. This makes it a popular choice for homes in rural regions of Australia.
Plus, insurance premiums can even be lower for homes built with steel frames.
5. Low Maintenance
Once installed, steel frames require very little maintenance.
There’s no need to treat the structure against pests or rot. Polishing is also not required and it won’t degrade over time.
Now, let’s move towards its downsides.
Cons of Steel Frames
Here are some of the risks you should consider while choosing steel frames for your home.
1. Higher Upfront Cost
Steel is more expensive than timber, both in materials and installation. These high costs and extra expenses can be a deal-breaker for those on a tight budget.
2. Pre-Fabrication Limits
Steel frames are pre-fabricated in factories to fit specific plans. While this can speed up the building process. It leaves little room for last-minute changes or adjustments on site.
3. Cold Feel
Steel is a poor insulator, which can lead to colder homes if the frame isn’t properly insulated.
Steel-framed homes can feel colder & uncomfortable in winter compared to timber frame houses. Plus, think about the extra expense you will have to spend on heating.
4. Corrosion Risk
While steel frames are galvanised or treated to prevent rust. But still, there is some risk of the corrosion. Especially if your home is located in a humid environment or coastal areas.
5. Noise & Creaking
Steel expands and contracts with temperature changes. That can lead to creaking voices in the walls. It is particularly noticeable & pretty annoying during temperature shifts at night.
Cold winds can also cause changes & noise in it.
Now, let’s talk about the other option you have, the timber framing.
Timber Frames | Traditional Base
Basic natural timber frame has always been used for houses in Australia. Gathered from trees like pine, it can be easily sourced and managed. For centuries, it has been providing the warmth and comfort to houses.
Many builders still rely on it for strength and longevity. While many homeowners choose it for its aesthetic element. However, there are some downsides to it too.
Let’s discuss the pros and cons of timber framing in detail.
Pros of Timber Frames
Building homes for ages, timber is still one of the most popular framing materials today. It offers a natural aesthetic, environmental benefits, and affordability for everyone.
Here are some advantages that keep it from becoming outdated in construction.
1. Natural Charm
One of the biggest reasons people choose timber frames is their timeless and comforting appearance. Nature always adds a solid character to everything.
Exposed traditional timber frames can enhance the aesthetics of your home. Especially in country-style houses or vintage designs.
2. Weight Resistance
Timber might not sound as strong as steel. But it’s incredibly weight-resistant. Especially high-quality framing timber like hardwood.
It can absorb shocks and vibrations better than steel. Making it a great option in areas prone to earthquakes or heavy winds.
3. Noise-Free Structure
Unlike steel, timber doesn’t expand or contract as much with temperature changes. This makes timber-framed homes quieter and more comfortable to live in.
However, keep in mind that it doesn’t provide any sound insulation.
4. Excellent Insulation
Timber naturally provides better heat insulation than steel. So, it can save some heating budget for your home.
This means homes built with timber frames are more energy-efficient. Keeping you warmer in winter and cooler in summer.
5. Environmentally Friendly
Timber is a renewable resource. Especially when sourced from responsibly managed forests. The carbon footprint of its cutting is much lower than steel mining.
Recycled or reclaimed wood can also be used. So, timber frames are one of the most eco-friendly building materials available.
6. Customisation and Flexibility
Timber frames are much easier to modify on site. They don’t come in pre-designed structures and offer more customisation to your needs.
If you want to adjust the size of a beam or cut new openings. Timber can be worked even with basic tools. Something that isn’t possible with pre-fabricated steel frames.
7. Affordable Option
Timber is cheaper than steel, both in materials and installation. It can be easily sourced from forests. You’ll not need much labour cost or complex manufacturing processes for it.
So, if you’re on a budget, timber frames can offer excellent value for your money.
Cons of Timber Frames
Despite the numerous benefits, these liabilities are also associated with the use of timber framing.
1. Fire Hazard
Wooden Frames are naturally flammable. So, buildings made with it are at a higher fire risk compared to steel.
However, modern treatments are available that can improve timber’s fire resistance.
2. Pest Risk
Timber frames of Australia are vulnerable to termites and wood-boring insects. Especially at the countryside or in warmer climates.
There is a solution to this problem too. You can treat it with pest resistance procedures.
3. Maintenance Requirements
The luxury and natural charm of timber isn’t free from straining maintenance needs.
Timber requires regular inspections, painting, and sealing. That can protect it from moisture, rot, and pests. You’ll also need frequent polishing to maintain its look.
Now, let’s conclude the debate
Steel Frames vs Timber Frames | Which is Best for Your Project?
Here’s a quick comparison of steel frames vs timber frames to help you decide.
If you’re looking for durability, pest resistance, low-maintenance, and fire safety. Steel is the better option for you.
But if you value natural aesthetics, flexibility, environmental sustainability, and cost-efficiency. Timber frames are hard to beat.
Ultimately, the right choice depends on your budget, design preferences, and the climate requirements in your area.
Looking to Buy Framing Timber Online at Best Prices?
Get Best Timber for Framing Your Dream Home with Ply Supply
Here at Ply Supply, we’re passionate about helping Australians build better homes. That’s why we supply the best quality materials. So, you can build what you love worry-free.
We’ve handpicked a range of high-quality framing timber, plywood, and decking materials. That can give you the best results and bring your vision to life. Whether you’re a DIYer or a builder, we’ve got the products to make your project easier.